Two are sentenced to death over toxic milk scandal

Chinese court rules that two men are to be executed after at least six babies died and 300,000 fell ill after drinking tainted milk powder

Two men are to be executed and one of China’s top dairy company bosses will spend the rest of her life in jail after at least six babies died and 300,000 fell ill after drinking infant milk powder that was deliberately tainted with an industrial chemical.

Outside the closed court distraught parents wept and railed against what they saw as the leniency of the sentence against the head of the dairy company Sanlu Group.

Some demanded that responsibility be laid on Communist Party officials, whom they blamed for assisting the cover-up and thus delaying a public announcement that Sanlu’s baby formula had been mixed with melamine. The nitrogen-rich chemical mixed into the milk fooled tests by appearing to boost the product’s protein content.

The severity of the first sentences to be announced reflected the sensitivity of a case involving milk products manufactured by a state-run venture that hid the scandal, apparently with the connivance of local officials, to avoid bad publicity during the Beijing Olympic Games in August last year.

All eyes had been on the sentencing of Tian Wenhua, 66, the former chairwoman and general manager of the Sanlu Group. She was the most senior official charged in the food safety crisis, which highlighted corporate and official shortcomings as well as corruption. She had pleaded guilty to charges of producing and selling fake or substandard products and received the maximum penalty of life imprisonment.

In her one-day court appearance Tian admitted that she knew of the problems for at least four months before notifying the authorities in August. Three of her colleagues were sentenced to terms from five to fifteen years. The court sentenced Zhang Yujun, 40, to death for running a workshop that was allegedly China’s largest source of melamine and had sold 600 tonnes to be mixed into milk.

Geng Jinping was given the death penalty for producing and selling toxic food, while Gao Junjie received a suspended death sentence, which is usually commuted to a life sentence. Public outrage has been widespread since it emerged in September that babies across China had been poisoned after being fed the tainted formula. Melamine, usually an ingredient in plastics and fertiliser, can cause kidney stones and kidney failure when it is ingested in large amounts.

Zheng Shuzhen, from the central Henan province, was outside the court to hear the verdict. Her one-year-old granddaughter died in June after drinking Sanlu milk. She said that Tian should be executed: “I’ve run out of tears . . . that’s why I came today.

“Even if she [Tian] dies a hundred times over, it won’t lessen our hate. She has brought such harm to the public, to children.”

Government officials had been reluctant to allow news of the problem to filter out and the few investigative Chinese journalists who had uncovered the scandal were unable to publish their findings.

One described later in a blog how he had tried to warn friends against Sanlu milk by word of mouth. The public finally heard about the scandal only after the New Zealand company Fonterra, a partner of the now-bankrupt Sanlu, told its Government and it blew the whistle.

The scandal is merely the latest to tarnish the “Made in China” brand. One of the deadliest cases in recent years also involved the most vulnerable in society. In 2004 at least 13 babies died after being fed fake baby formula of no nutritional value. The media showed poignant images of infants with emaciated bodies, their heads swollen with malnutrition.

The question now will be whether the executions — the sentences are likely to be upheld on appeal — will make any difference in a system where checks and balances are weak, consumers often poorly educated and corruption greases the wheels of business.

Deadly scam

— Melamine is a white powder used in plastic-making. It was synthesised by a German scientist in the 1830s

— Its most common form, melamine resin, a mix of melamine and formaldehyde, is used in the manufacture of Formica, floor tiles, whiteboards and kitchenware

— Adding nitrogen-rich melamine to sub-standard or watered-down milk powder makes the protein level appear higher because standard quality tests estimate protein levels by measuring nitrogen content

— In the wake of the scandal the EU banned all imports of baby food products made in China containing traces of milk and introduced tests on all imported food made with at least 15 per cent Chinese milk or milk powder
Jane McCartney in Beijing
******************************************************************************************
This is a portrait of the Sanlu Group through the lens of a business new source:
http://investing.businessweek.com/research/stocks/private/snapshot.asp?p...

Do you think anyone should be executed for their part in this occurrence?

What do you think appropriate punishment/ legal recourse is?

Who do you think is to blame?
******************************************************************************************